Its all about the Installer. Sorry i cant help with the closest color, but i cna speak for there kits. Loved mine in my last Challenger
My seats are identical to OEM leather fit and finish wise. I just went on autotraer and looked at used cars(those pics are not when new) and the fit is identical.Even so, why have I never seen one done that looks right? Surely someone knows how to do it right. Maybe I'm losing my mind lol. So many people are in love with theirs yet when I see theirs I know I wouldnt like it. Really odd, maybe I'm just too picky.